FINA trans swim policy shows ‘equal but separate’ is actually exclusion

This column was written by Shireen Ahmed for CBC Sports. For more information, visit Opinion section of CBCPlease refer to the FAQ.
On Sunday night, the international governing body of water sports (FINA) effectively banned transgender women from competition. FINA called it a gender inclusion policy, but in reality it excludes transgender women. It took effect Monday.
To be eligible for traditional women’s categories, trans women athletes must have completed sex transition (transition) by age 12. FINA may give an advantage to trans women who have experienced puberty in a male gender.
In an attempt to not appear blatantly exclusionary, FINA has formed a working group to create an “open” category for trans women to be able to participate in some events. No one is quite sure what “open” entails — including FINA, which will spend the next six months trying to parse it out. It seems to be a random “equal but distinct” plot.
The reality is that all these barriers render it highly unlikely that trans women will have an opportunity to participate in any FINA events, which also include diving, water polo, artistic swimming, high diving and open water swimming. Chris Mosier, trans activist and triathlete tweeted: “This is probably the largest ban on transgender women in sport that we’ve ever seen.”
Trans activists have been vocal about how trans people feel Harmful and unfair These policies are. It is unacceptable to invalidate someone’s identity because of the propaganda against trans communities.
Police take control of women’s bodies
Hijab-wearing women like me were prohibited from playing professional basketball and soccer due to policies made largely by men in the boardrooms. They were often ill-advised and pushed by women who believed that all women wearing headscarves were oppressed. They believed that hijab was dangerous and should not be worn on the pitch or court. This is incorrect, we know. They never consulted me or my community. And for years women’s bodies were policed and they were excluded from sports. It will take generations before they are able to participate in elite sports at such levels.
Now, fast forward. How many trans athletes and advocates were there in the creation of this policy. Who is seated at the table in this working group? We are aware of an American “working group“that is viciously anti trans and whose agenda to exclude trans youth from all sports.” Selective inclusion does not equal inclusion.
Trans women are not allowed to participate in sports, which does not pose a threat to women’s sport. The frantic and erratic manner in which this issue is navigated would seem like there is a crisis or war against women in sport. This isIncorrect and absurd.
James Pearce, spokesperson for FINA president Husain al-Musallam, said The Associated PressThere are no trans women swimming at the elite level. None. This moral panic is unneeded and hurts sport.
The worst part is Other federationsIt is possible that others will follow their lead.
USA Swimming enacted a new policy regarding transgender inclusions earlier this year. This ended the career of University of Pennsylvania swimmer Lia Thomas. Thomas was the focus of much debate because of her winning times. She was also deemed a threat for women’s sports. This is Unquestionably false.
Thomas’ swimming career is almost over. Interview with CNNThomas shared an important fact about trans athletes in May. “Trans people don’t transition for athletics. We transition to be happy, authentic, and true to ourselves.
Trans people don’t transition for athletics. We transition to be happy, authentic and true to ourselves.– Swimmer Lia Thomas
U.S. women’s soccer team star Megan Rapinoe BelievesInclusion is key. “Show me the evidence of trans women winning every title, taking all scholarships, dominating in every sport.” It’s not happening, I’m sorry.
FINA’s policy against FINA is a violation of the Sixth Principle in the Olympic Charter, which states: “Any form discrimination with respect to a country, or a person based on race, religion or politics, gender, or any other basis, is incompatible with being a member of the Olympic Movement.” The policy is not compatible with Principles of 2021 International Olympic CommitteeHuman rights. The IOC guidelines changed from determining eligibility based on testosterone levels to allowing individual sports to decide.
I asked Dr. Katrina Karkazis, bioethicist, AuthorAmherst College professor, to explain why FINA is flawed.
“This policy contradicts the recent IOC framework that is grounded in human rights principles, and says policies like these could violate bodily integrity as well as privacy,” she wrote. “The new policy uses an outdated interventionist clinical framework, which many UN agencies and governments have used.” said”Violate human rights” and use an open category for punishment for those who refuse medicalization of their bodies.
Dr. Karkazis said the evidence used to uphold transphobic policies is also flawed.
“The IOC framework urges that policies be free from presumption or advantage and based on solid evidence. FINA has not made public the evidence they have reviewed nor the reviewer, but many studies that have been cited conclude that there isn’t enough scientific evidence for specific policies about intersex or transgender athletes. This is not surprising considering this is a relatively new area of research.
FINA’s inexplicable science behind these policies is alarming and dangerous. FINA’s separate but equal approach to banning people in sport is fueling transphobic behavior in society. We know that trans children are watching, and we know they are there. risk for mental health strugglesThey can also create barriers. They are especially targeted when politicians restrict or ban their access to healthcare.
We all know that sports federations are sometimes on the wrong side. This is another example.
Source: CBC Sports




